EDR Buyer's Guide 2026: Choose by what happens before the code runs

CEO CSIBy Vincent Sullivan, former Technical Director, U.S. Cyber CommandUpdated October 202613 min read
The short answerChoose EDR by architecture first and features second. Detect-and-respond EDR lets unknown code run and acts when behavior looks malicious, so it needs people watching. Allowlisting blocks anything unapproved and needs people maintaining lists. Containment runs unknown code in isolation until it has a verdict. Match the architecture to the staff you actually have, then test vendors on evidence, packaging and fully loaded price.

Disclosure: CSI resells Warden, built on Xcitium ZeroDwell. This guide uses public, dated sources and states where other architectures fit better.

Which architecture fits your team?Fit finder

Pick your staffing level. Rows that need more people than you have will fade.

Architecture vs staffing
ArchitectureWho must act
Detect-and-respond EDRYour analysts, on every alert, around the clock
EDR plus managed MDRThe provider's analysts; you approve actions they can't take
Default-deny allowlistingYour admins, maintaining the approved list
Containment of unknownsNo one at execution time; you review verdicts

Definitions

What EDR is, in the definitions buyers are held to

The U.S. government defines endpoint detection and response as real-time, continuous monitoring and collection of endpoint data, combined with rules-based automated response and analysis.[1] The Center for Internet Security describes the same thing in plainer terms: software on workstations and servers that collects endpoint data continuously, analyzes it, responds automatically and supports remote investigation and remediation. Many EDR products include antivirus as one component.[2]

Executive Order 14028 made EDR mandatory across federal civilian agencies in 2021, covering proactive detection, active hunting, containment and remediation.[3] The memo that implemented it, OMB M-22-01, also required agencies to make sure their EDR was properly resourced and staffed.[1] That detail matters more than any feature list. EDR, as most products define it, is a sensor plus a response workflow. The workflow assumes people.

So the first buying question is not which vendor has the best detection score. It is what happens to an unknown file in the seconds after it lands, and who has to be awake for that answer to be good. The rest of this guide works through that question, then the evidence, the price and the pilot. If you already have a shortlist, jump to the EDR comparison hub or the vendor reviews linked at the end.

The 2026 evidence

What the latest breach data says about your choice

Three annual datasets carry most of the weight in this market. Their 2026 editions point the same way: attackers are getting in through flaws faster than anyone patches, and ransomware is still the payoff.

Breach data that should shape an EDR decision
FindingFigureWhy it matters for EDR
Global median dwell time, 2025 [4]14 days (up from 11)Across Mandiant's investigations, attackers were inside for two weeks at the median before discovery.
Top initial infection vector, 2025 [5]Exploits, 32% (sixth year running)The entry point is often a flaw, not a user click. Training alone won't close it.
Mean time to exploit, 2025 [5]Negative 7 daysOn average, exploitation began before a patch existed. Prevention can't depend on knowing the threat first.
How ransomware intrusions came to light [4]Attacker told the victim in 44% of casesIn ransomware cases the extortion note was the most common detection source.
Breaches involving ransomware [6]48% (up from 44%)Ransomware is present in nearly half of confirmed breaches.
Exploitation as initial access [6]31% (up from 20%)Verizon calls it the most prominent initial access vector in its dataset.
Known-exploited flaws fully fixed [6]26%, median 43 daysMost known-exploited flaws stay open for weeks after a fix ships.
Ransomware share of SMB breaches, 2025 report [7]88% (vs 39% at large orgs)Ransomware is involved in almost nine of ten small-business breaches.
Attacks that encrypted data, 2026 survey [8]56%More than half of attacks still reach encryption.
Average recovery cost, 2026 survey [8]$1.7MThe bill for a failed prevention decision.
Smaller organizations that stopped the attack before encryption [8]About 1 in 3Two of three smaller victims were stopped too late or not at all.

Read together, the numbers make one argument. If the attacker's code is new to the world, or arrives through a flaw nobody has patched, a product that decides by recognizing bad behavior has to watch that behavior happen first. Long dwell times show how costly late discovery is. The rest of this guide asks how each architecture handles it.

Architecture first

The three architectures, and what each does with an unknown file

Most comparison content ranks vendors on features. Features change every quarter. Architecture doesn't, and it decides your staffing bill. Every product on a typical shortlist uses one of three approaches to code it hasn't seen before.

1. Detect and respond

CSI places CrowdStrike Falcon and SentinelOne Singularity in this group. Known-bad files are blocked, machine learning scores unknown files before they run, and, in CSI's analysis, a file the model does not block is allowed to execute. The agent then watches behavior. When a pattern crosses a threshold, it alerts, and either the product or a person responds. CrowdStrike frames this with indicators of attack: behavioral signals of what an attacker is trying to do.[9] The strength is broad visibility and mature response tooling. The cost is that someone has to own the alerts, at 3 a.m. too.

2. Default-deny allowlisting

Anything not on an approved list doesn't run. NIST's guide to application whitelisting describes the approach as permitting known good activity and blocking everything else. It recommends it strongly for high-risk hosts, but calls it generally impractical for small or standalone environments without central management, and recommends dedicated staff to maintain the lists.[10] Australia's cyber agency rated application control Essential, one of eight baseline strategies, in its 2017 guidance.[11] The strength is that unknown code never executes. The cost is list maintenance and the friction of every legitimate new tool.

3. Containment of unknowns

Unknown code runs, but inside an isolated environment that can't write to the real host, while the file is analyzed. NIST lists sandboxing and virtualization-based segregation among its malware prevention controls.[12] Xcitium says users keep working and nothing is written to the host until there is a verdict. CSI's Warden, built on Xcitium ZeroDwell, takes this approach. Xcitium describes it as default-deny for unknowns: unknown executables run in a virtual container with no access to host resources or user data, while its Verdict Cloud analyzes them.[13][14] The strength is that no one has to make a decision at execution time. The cost is that you depend on the verdict service and must accept a contained period for new software.

The three architectures side by side
QuestionDetect and respondDefault-deny allowlistingContainment of unknowns
What happens to an unknown file?Allowed to execute unless the model blocks itBlocked until approvedRuns isolated; can't write to the host
Who decides at execution time?The model, then an analyst if behavior alertsThe list, maintained by adminsNo one; Xcitium says isolation is automatic
What does the team do daily?Triage alerts, investigate, respondApprove requests, update listsReview verdicts and release legitimate tools
Typical failure modeA file the model misses acts before it is flaggedBusiness friction pushes teams to loosen the listVerdict delays on niche software
Standards anchorOMB M-22-01 EDR definition [1]NIST SP 800-167 [10]NIST SP 800-83 sandboxing and virtualization [12]
Example productsCrowdStrike, SentinelOneThreatLocker, AppLocker, WDACWarden (Xcitium ZeroDwell)
Same unknown file. Two outcomes.Endpoint timeline
Detect-and-respond EDRRuns on the host
  1. 01File lands
  2. 02Runs on host
  3. 03Behavior builds
  4. 04Behavior flagged
  5. 05Agent or analyst responds
Warden containmentHost untouched
  1. 01File lands
  2. 02Contained
  3. 03Analyzed
  4. 04Verdict
  5. 05Released or discarded
Xcitium says its containment runs unknown code under kernel-level API virtualization with write access to the host denied while the file is analyzed. In CSI's analysis, detection-first tools allow a file the model does not block to execute, then act on its behavior.

The figure is the whole argument in one frame. Both lanes see the same file. One lets it run and builds a case; the other isolates it first and builds the case afterward. CISA's ransomware guide asks for application allowlisting and/or EDR on all assets, which covers both families.[15] For a deeper look at allowlisting versus containment, see Warden vs ThreatLocker and ThreatLocker alternatives.

Due diligence

Twelve questions to ask every EDR vendor

Ask each vendor the same questions, in writing, and score the answers yourself. Vague answers are answers.

  1. What happens to an unknown executable in its first second? Ask for the default policy, not the best-case configuration.
  2. Which decisions run on the endpoint, and which need the cloud? This determines what happens to an offline laptop.
  3. Who acts on an alert at 3 a.m. on a Sunday? If the answer is "you," price the staff.
  4. Which tier includes EDR, and which tiers are only antivirus? Several published bundles exclude EDR at the entry price.[16][17]
  5. How many days of telemetry are retained by default, and what does more cost? SentinelOne publishes 14 to 90 days depending on tier; we found no public CrowdStrike page stating default retention by tier.[18][19]
  6. What independent tests has the product entered in the last 18 months? Ask which ones it skipped, and why.
  7. How are content and sensor updates staged, and can we control timing? After July 2024 this is a board question.[20]
  8. What did your last major incident or outage look like, and where is the root-cause report?
  9. Can a local administrator disable or downgrade the agent? Check the tamper and upgrade-authorization settings.[21]
  10. What does migration away from you look like? Which policies, exclusions and history can we export, and in what format?
  11. What is the fully loaded annual cost for our device count? License plus managed service plus internal hours.
  12. Will you run a side-by-side pilot alongside our current tool? Vendors who believe their architecture will say yes.

Evidence

How to read independent test results without being sold

MITRE ATT&CK Evaluations are the most cited, and the most misread. MITRE states plainly that the evaluations do not rank vendors.[22] They show how a product saw and stopped a specific emulated adversary. The 2025 Enterprise round emulated Scattered Spider and Mustang Panda, tested attacks inside cloud infrastructure for the first time, and had 11 participants, including CrowdStrike.[22]

The bigger story of 2025 was who left. Microsoft withdrew in June, citing its Secure Future Initiative, and SentinelOne and Palo Alto Networks followed in September, each citing its platform roadmap.[23][24][25] MITRE's CTO acknowledged the round may have been made too hard and promised to restore the vendor forum.[23] The 2024 round, by contrast, had 19 participants and tested LockBit and CL0P-style ransomware.[26] SecurityWeek cautioned that vendor "100%" claims can cherry-pick favorable slices of the results.[27]

Use tests three ways. First, as a floor: a product that won't enter any public test is asking for trust it hasn't earned. Second, by scenario: read the steps that match your threats, not the headline. Third, by false positives: AV-Comparatives publishes false-alarm counts alongside protection rates, and a noisy product costs analyst time.[28] One honest note: Xcitium, which powers Warden, doesn't take part in MITRE Enterprise rounds. It publishes weekly telemetry and has that data audited instead, which we cover on the Warden page and the weekly record.[29][30]

Cost

What EDR costs: the published list prices

CrowdStrike and SentinelOne publish list prices. Treat these as ceilings: volume and multi-year deals change them, and the top and managed tiers are quote-only.

Published EDR list prices, per device per year
Product tierList priceIncludes EDR?Notes
CrowdStrike Falcon Go [16]$59.99NoAntivirus, device control, mobile; capped at 100 devices
CrowdStrike Falcon Pro [17]$99.99NoAdds firewall management
CrowdStrike Falcon Enterprise [31]$184.99YesAdds EDR and threat intelligence and hunting
CrowdStrike Falcon Complete [32]Quote onlyYesManaged detection and response
SentinelOne Singularity Complete [18]$179.99Yes14-day retention; price shown for 5 to 100 workstations
SentinelOne Singularity Commercial [18]$229.99Yes90-day retention, managed threat hunting
SentinelOne Singularity Enterprise [18]Quote onlyYesAdds agentic AI triage and network forensics

Note the trap in the first two rows. The cheapest published CrowdStrike tiers are next-generation antivirus without EDR. For the full tier-by-tier breakdown and a cost calculator, see CrowdStrike Falcon pricing. CSI does not publish a Warden list price; per-endpoint figures on our comparison pages are modeled scenarios. Quotes depend on device count and whether you add the managed service.

The hidden line item

The staffing math nobody puts on the quote

The license is the smaller number for most buyers. The larger one is the people who make a detect-and-respond product work: the analyst who triages a detection, the engineer who tunes exclusions, the on-call rota that covers nights. OMB requires federal agencies to resource and staff their EDR.[1] Vendors sell for this gap: CrowdStrike offers Falcon Complete and SentinelOne offers Wayfinder MDR for customers who don't staff a 24/7 queue.[33][34]

A simple way to price it: estimate the weekly hours your team spends on endpoint alerts, multiply by 52 and by a loaded hourly rate, and add any managed-service fee. Five hours a week at $85 an hour is $22,100 a year before a single incident. If that number is bigger than you expected, read EDR without a SOC. It lays out what changes when the architecture removes the triage queue instead of outsourcing it.

Watch forQuotes that bundle MDR "response" but leave containment approval, recovery and incident response retainers to you. Ask the provider to list exactly which actions they take without calling you first.

Proof

Run a 30-day pilot that settles the decision

Paper evaluations favor the best marketing. A side-by-side pilot favors the best architecture. Keep it short and measurable.

  1. Pick 25 to 50 endpoints that reflect your real fleet, including the awkward ones: finance laptops, a build server, a kiosk.
  2. Run the candidate alongside your current tool, not instead of it. Coexistence is a requirement, not a favor.
  3. Measure four things weekly: alerts generated, alerts that needed a human, legitimate software blocked or contained, and hours spent.
  4. Replay a safe attack simulation on a test host and record the timeline from file landing to stop.
  5. Price the result fully loaded: license, managed service and the hours you measured.

CSI runs Warden pilots this way, alongside the incumbent. If you are leaving CrowdStrike, start with how to export your Falcon data and the CrowdStrike migration guide.

Shortlist

Where to go next, by vendor

Each page below uses the same rubric and cites its sources, so you can compare them line by line.

Methodology

How this guide was built

Every figure comes from a public source opened on the research date and listed at the end of this page. Prices are list prices as published on vendor sites on that date. Vendor performance claims are labeled as vendor claims. CSI has not run hands-on tests of CrowdStrike or SentinelOne for this guide. We refresh the guide every 90 days, or sooner when a vendor changes its packaging.

Disclosure: CSI resells Warden, built on Xcitium ZeroDwell. That is why this guide explains containment in detail. It is also why performance claims about Warden are attributed to Xcitium or to the named auditor, and why the guide states where detect-and-respond products are the better fit: a staffed 24/7 SOC that wants deep telemetry and mature hunting tools.

FAQ

EDR buying questions

What is the difference between EDR and antivirus?

Antivirus focuses on blocking known and suspected malware files. EDR adds continuous monitoring, data collection and response tooling so a team can investigate and act on threats that get past prevention. The U.S. government definition stresses continuous monitoring plus automated response.[1] Several entry-level bundles sold as endpoint protection are antivirus without EDR, so check the tier.

Do small businesses need EDR?

Verizon's 2025 report found ransomware in 88% of small-business breaches versus 39% at large organizations.[7] What small businesses usually lack is not a sensor but staff to respond, so the architecture and any managed service matter more than the feature list.

Is MITRE ATT&CK Evaluations a ranking of the best EDR?

No. MITRE states that the evaluations do not rank vendors.[22] They show how each product handled specific emulated attacks. Microsoft, SentinelOne and Palo Alto Networks skipped the 2025 round, so a missing result is not evidence of a weak product.[23]

What is the difference between allowlisting and containment?

Allowlisting blocks anything not on an approved list, which stops unknown code but requires staff to maintain the list.[10] Containment lets unknown code run inside an isolated environment that cannot write to the host while the file is analyzed, so users keep working and no list has to be maintained.[13]

How much does EDR cost per device?

Published list prices range from $59.99 per device per year for CrowdStrike Falcon Go, which does not include EDR, to $229.99 for SentinelOne Singularity Commercial.[16][18] Enterprise and managed tiers are quote-only. Staffing usually costs more than the license.

Can I run two EDR products at once during a pilot?

Usually yes, with exclusions configured so the two agents ignore each other. Running side by side is the most reliable way to compare alert volume, blocked software and hours spent. Ask each vendor for its coexistence guidance before the pilot starts.

What should I ask about vendor update safety after the 2024 CrowdStrike outage?

Ask how content and sensor updates are staged, whether you can delay or ring-fence them, and where the vendor publishes root-cause reports. CrowdStrike committed to staged deployment and customer control over rapid-response content after its July 2024 incident.[20]

Next step

Test the architecture on your own endpoints

A side-by-side pilot runs Warden next to your current EDR for 30 days and measures alerts, contained files and hours spent. No rip and replace.

Vincent Sullivan

Vincent Sullivan, founder and CEO of Cyber Strategy Institute. Twenty-two years as a U.S. Air Force cyber officer, finishing as Technical Director at U.S. Cyber Command. CSI designs prevention-first security architecture and publishes AI SAFE², an open AI governance framework.

About CSI and the team

Sources

Sources and research date

Every figure on this page links to the public source below. Research date: Oct 3, 2026. Vendor claims are labeled as vendor claims.

  1. OMB M-22-01: Improving Detection through EDR. The White House (OMB). https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/M-22-01.pdf. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  2. Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) spotlight. Center for Internet Security. https://www.cisecurity.org/insights/spotlight/cybersecurity-spotlight-endpoint-detection-and-response-edr. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  3. Executive Order 14028, Improving the Nation's Cybersecurity. Federal Register. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2021/05/17/2021-10460/improving-the-nations-cybersecurity. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  4. M-Trends 2026 Executive Edition. Mandiant. https://services.google.com/fh/files/misc/m-trends-2026-executive-edition-en.pdf. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  5. M-Trends 2026: Data, Insights, and Strategies From the Frontlines. Google Cloud (Mandiant). https://cloud.google.com/blog/topics/threat-intelligence/m-trends-2026. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  6. 2026 Data Breach Investigations Report. Verizon. https://www.verizon.com/business/resources/Td15/reports/2026-dbir-data-breach-investigations-report.pdf. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  7. 2025 Data Breach Investigations Report. Verizon. https://www.verizon.com/business/resources/reports/2025-dbir-data-breach-investigations-report.pdf. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  8. State of Ransomware 2026. Sophos. https://www.sophos.com/en-us/content/state-of-ransomware. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  9. IOA vs IOC. CrowdStrike. https://www.crowdstrike.com/en-us/cybersecurity-101/threat-intelligence/ioa-vs-ioc/. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  10. NIST SP 800-167, Guide to Application Whitelisting. NIST. https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/SpecialPublications/NIST.SP.800-167.pdf. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  11. Strategies to Mitigate Cyber Security Incidents (ACSC, mirror). Australian Cyber Security Centre. https://database.cyberpolicyportal.org/api/files/1659689647802qgzxrf9zfxp.pdf. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  12. NIST SP 800-83 Rev. 1, Guide to Malware Incident Prevention and Handling. NIST. https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/SpecialPublications/NIST.SP.800-83r1.pdf. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  13. How Xcitium ZeroDwell works. Xcitium. https://www.xcitium.com/how-xcitium-zerodwell-works-how-it-works-against-malware/. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  14. Valkyrie Cloud File Analysis Platform. Xcitium. https://enterprise.xcitium.com/valkyrie/. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  15. #StopRansomware Guide. CISA. https://www.cisa.gov/stopransomware/ransomware-guide. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  16. Falcon Go pricing page. CrowdStrike. https://www.crowdstrike.com/en-us/pricing/falcon-go/. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  17. Falcon Pro pricing page. CrowdStrike. https://www.crowdstrike.com/en-us/pricing/falcon-pro/. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  18. SentinelOne Pricing and Package Comparison. SentinelOne. https://www.sentinelone.com/pricing/. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  19. Falcon Search Retention data sheet. CrowdStrike. https://www.crowdstrike.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Falcon-Search-Data_Retention_V2.pdf. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  20. External Technical Root Cause Analysis: Channel File 291 (Aug 6, 2024). CrowdStrike. https://www.crowdstrike.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/Channel-File-291-Incident-Root-Cause-Analysis-08.06.2024.pdf. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  21. 'Bring Your Own Installer' Attack Targets SentinelOne EDR. Dark Reading. https://www.darkreading.com/vulnerabilities-threats/bring-your-own-installer-attack-sentinelone-edr. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  22. MITRE ATT&CK Evaluations Advance Cloud Security and Counter-Espionage Capabilities. MITRE. https://www.mitre.org/news-insights/news-release/mitre-attck-evaluations-advance-cloud-security-and-counter-espionage. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  23. Cyber Threat Detection Vendors Pull Out of MITRE Evaluations Test. Infosecurity Magazine. https://www.infosecurity-magazine.com/news/cyber-vendors-pull-out-mitre/. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  24. SentinelOne and the MITRE ATT&CK Evaluations: Enterprise 2025. SentinelOne. https://www.sentinelone.com/blog/sentinelone-and-the-mitre-attck-evaluations-enterprise-2025/. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  25. Palo Alto Networks and MITRE ATT&CK Evaluations: Enterprise 2025. Palo Alto Networks. https://www.paloaltonetworks.com/blog/security-operations/palo-alto-networks-and-mitre-attck-evaluations-enterprise-2025/. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  26. MITRE Posts Latest Findings of ATT&CK Evaluations Against Ransomware. MITRE. https://www.mitre.org/news-insights/news-release/mitre-posts-latest-findings-attack-evaluations-cybersecurity-solutions. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  27. MITRE Posts Results of 2025 ATT&CK Enterprise Evaluations. SecurityWeek. https://www.securityweek.com/mitre-posts-results-of-2025-attck-enterprise-evaluations/. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  28. Business Security Test 2025 (August to November). AV-Comparatives. https://av-comparatives.org/tests/business-security-test-2025-august-november/. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  29. Xcitium Threat Labs data statistics (performance transparency). Xcitium. https://www.xcitium.com/resources/threat-labs/data-statistics/. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  30. MRG Effitas 360: Xcitium Transparency Page Q1 2025. MRG Effitas (hosted by Xcitium). https://www.xcitium.com/pdf/MRG_Effitas_Q1_2025_Xcitium_Transparency_Page_v110.pdf. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  31. Falcon Enterprise pricing page. CrowdStrike. https://www.crowdstrike.com/en-us/pricing/falcon-enterprise/. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  32. CrowdStrike pricing page. CrowdStrike. https://www.crowdstrike.com/en-us/pricing/. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  33. Falcon Complete Next-Gen MDR data sheet. CrowdStrike. https://www.crowdstrike.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/falcon-complete-next-gen-mdr-data-sheet.pdf. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.
  34. Introduction of Wayfinder Threat Detection and Response. SentinelOne. https://www.sentinelone.com/press/sentinelone-introduction-of-wayfinder-threat-detection-and-response-in-partnership-with-google-cloud/. Accessed Oct 3, 2026.

Stop Threats Before They Execute

Your free Kernel-Level Defense Buyer’s Guide is ready to download.

By providing my email address, I consent to receive emails and text messages—including newsletters and marketing communications—from creators of Warden Secure, Cyber Strategy Institute, our flagship zero-trust platform for ransomware prevention, and agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.